The Chaos Sanctuary

A Website Dedicated to Diablo II Classic (non-expansion)

BvB Comprehensive PvP Guide

All Barbarian builds · Back to All Builds/Guides

The BvB (Barbarian vs Barbarian) Spreadsheet is a duel calculator for head-to-head Barbarian PvP. It works out the most efficient base Strength for your Barbarian, and compares two complete Barbarians (gear, stats and skills) to show which one should win an average straight duel.

Download the BvB Spreadsheet (v3.01, Excel, 1.7 MB)

Open it in Microsoft Excel. It is an Excel template (.xltx), so Excel opens a new copy each time, leaving the original untouched. The Competition sheet is laid out for a 1920×1200 screen.

Credits and versions

Thanks to Naek and Njeng for their help. Information was mainly taken from indiablo.de, mannm.org (D2 Library faqtoids) and diablowiki.net.

BaseSTR sheet: the most efficient base Strength

  1. Use the purple dropdowns to set up your Barbarian's stats. Set skill levels with Battle Command active (commonly 21).
  2. If you use a pre-LoD Executioner's Sword, add max damage manually until the displayed Max DMG matches your sword's max damage in game (some pre-LoD Execs calculate max damage oddly).
  3. Check the blue box on the right. It must show a number below 33; if it says "false", your damage is too low to calculate.
  4. In the table at the top, find the biggest value in the ALL WINS column and read the base Strength on the left. If several rows tie, pick the one with the most WINS.
  5. That is the most efficient base Strength for your level and gear.

Competition sheet: compare two Barbarians

A large calculation to find the best gear and build for your Barbarian. It only covers straight head-to-head duels.

  1. Set up all the salmon dropdowns:
    • Items: choose the "Rare" preset for rares, magic items and 6-socket weapons; common uniques have their own presets. To adjust a non-rare preset (for example a different Defense, or socketed), correct the stats with Special Add (negative values work, but use them carefully). Some pre-LoD Execs need their max damage corrected the same way.
    • Base stats and skill levels: for each Barbarian, set character level, base Strength, base Dexterity (Exec Barbarians), poison resist (needed for duels with poison damage) and skill levels. Battle Command is added automatically if you put 1 point in it.
    • Duel settings: "Damage Breakpoints" turns on in-game rounding; set it to NO when comparing single stats or items. "Range and Weapon Gain" = YES accounts for the advantage of your weapon type against your opponent's (based on the author's in-game testing). "Hits per Second" matters for replenish life, poison and bleed damage: set it so the duel lasts a realistic time (from the first hit until death).
  2. Set up all the blue dropdowns wherever you chose a "Rare" or "3-Sock" preset. Special Add is for testing and for special items such as socketed uniques, which aren't saved as presets.
  3. The Points then show which Barbarian tends to win an average head-to-head duel.